Over 30 Years Of Building

John N. Mason, CIC started Chenango Brokers over 30 years ago and since then he has consulted numerous agencies across the United States and Canada and expanded the business into what it is today.

There are many things that set Chenango Brokers apart from other agencies including:

We strive to deliver quotes to our producers in 37 minutes or less (on products we can quote in-house based on a fully-completed application on the first submission). We don’t make our producers wait to be paid THEIR commissions. All direct bill commissions are paid to the retail producer on the 1st Friday of the month after we receive it.

We use regional carriers who understand the marketplace where the risk is located. We also represent many carriers not traditionally found in the wholesale marketplace.

Whether you are looking for commercial or residential insurance we want to be your wholesaler of choice. Contact us today for more information.


Our Mission

Chenango Brokers strives to provide our agents with the products necessary to protect their business and personal insurance clients with quality products and affordable pricing.


We’re Green!

Chenango Brokers has been almost entirely paperless since 2002. Using dual monitors and a state-of-the-art imaging system our staff has been able to eliminate most paper in-house and deliver mail to our producers electronically for many years.

Ssssshhhh… my new tell-all book “Follow the Money” reveals more shocking secrets than a round-the-clock confessional. 

Our Office

PO Box 460
65 West Front Steet Ext
Hancock, NY 13783
See Google Map

Contact Us

Toll-Free: 800-403-3738
Toll-Free Fax: 888-488-6757

Office Hours 

Mon-Thur: 8:30am ET- 5pm ET
Fri: 8:30am ET - 4pm ET
Sat-Sun: Closed

New Business

Trish – Underwriter

Direct: 347-821-3215
800-403-3738 x120
trishc @chenangobrokers.com

Theresa – Underwriter

Direct: 347-269-1574
800-403-3738 x115
[email protected]

Miranda – Underwriter

Direct: 347-821-3221
800-403-3738 x103
[email protected]

Dulcie – Underwriter

Direct: 347-821-3225
800-403-3738 x104
[email protected]

Audrey – Underwriter

Direct: 347-821-3228
800-403-3738 x105
[email protected]

Customer Service

Alle-Team Leader/Certificates

Direct: 347-821-3216
800-403-3738 x107
[email protected]

Kaitlin - Customer Service

Direct: 347-821-3244
800-403-3738 x113
[email protected]


Jamie Deapo-Agency Relations Manager

Direct: 347-269-1645
800-403-3738 x116
[email protected]

Office Manager

Robin Bartholomew

Direct: 347-821-3249
800-403-3738 x101
[email protected]