Contact Us

Chenango Brokers, LLC
Toll-Free: 800-403-3738
Toll-Free Fax: 888-488-6757
PO Box 460, Hancock, NY 13783

More Contacts

New Business

Dawn – Underwriter
Direct: 347-821-3215
Toll-Free: 800-403-3738 x102

Miranda – Underwriter
Direct: 347-821-3221
Toll-Free: 800-403-3738 x103

Dulcie – Underwriter
Direct: 347-821-3225
Toll-Free: 800-403-3738 x104

Alle – Underwriter & Certificates
Direct: 347-821-3216
Toll-Free: 800-403-3738 x107


Joann – Customer Service
Direct: 347-821-3228
Toll-Free: 800-403-3738 x105

Kylee - Customer Service
Direct: 347-821-3244
Toll-Free: 800-403-3738 x113

Krissy – Document Filing
Direct: 347-821-3206
Toll-Free: 800-403-3738 x114

Office Manager

Robin Bartholomew
Direct: 347-821-3249
Toll-Free: 800-403-3738 x101

Our Services

Chenango Brokers offers a variety of insurances including (but not limited to):

  • Commercial auto Insurance
  • Fleet Insurance
  • Worker’s Comp Insurance
  • Restaurant Insurance
  • Bar Insurance
  • Dram Shop Insurance
  • Deli Insurance
  • Pizzeria Insurance
  • Garage Insurance
  • Garagekeepers Legal Liability
  • Auto Body Insurance
  • Transmission Shop Insurance
  • Detail Shop Insurance
  • Sound And Stereo Shop Insurance
  • Office Insurance
  • Strip Mall Insurance
  • Condo Association Insurance
  • Landlord Insurance
  • Homeowner Insurance
  • Car Insurance
  • Umbrella Insurance
  • General Contractor Insurance
  • Roofer Insurance
  • Electrician Insurance
  • HVAC Insurance
  • General Liability

Our Top 5 services

  1. Assisting our producers in finding competitive and comprehensive products for their clients based on the information provided to us.
  2. Matching our producers with online products that they can rate in their own offices.
  3. Providing service in far more timely manner than other wholesale brokers.
  4. Providing captive and smaller agents the opportunity to place business in markets they would not otherwise have access to.
  5. When a small agent loses a direct market due to low volume, or has had service issues with another wholesaler, we can often help that agent retain his or her business by moving the impacted customers seamlessly into Chenango Brokers.


John N. Mason, CIC, has been in the insurance industry since 1988 and has consulted numerous agencies across the United States and Canada on how to better run and market their agencies on a fee basis. Services run $1600.00 per 8 hour day plus reasonable travel expense. A two day consultation would include a SWOT analysis, frank discussion with staff members which usually reveals problems the principal isn’t even aware of, and an implementation plan.